• researcher
  • contact
  • Friday, 17 November 2017

    Designing infographics on educational inequalities in Cape Town's wards- a new #UCT Media Studies project.

    Written for Media Studies educators interested in teaching data journalism and infographic poster design.

    A new infographic poster design course (FAM2017S)


    Professor Marion Walton, Dr Martha Evans and I recently prepared a five week course in which I taught second year journalism students to design infographic posters that focused on educational inequalities in two Cape Town wards.

    The course comprised the following lessons (which dovetailed with Martha's on article layout):
    week 1: Introducing typography;
    week 2: Designing an online identity using type, shapes and paths;
    week 3: Introducing infographics and preparing a poster template;
    week 4: Exporting data from youthexplorer.org.za and designing charts;
    week 5: Short infographic poster presentations by students for assessment.

    All students had access to the Mendi lab, where they could learn to use Adobe Illustrator for detailed design work and Microsoft Excel for chart design. Most students had already been to a workshop that introduced them to youthexplorer.org.za. I taught its use for exporting Excel files, cleaning their data and preparing various comparative charts. Students also had the option of using Adobe InDesign in class or a similar alternative at home.

    A diverse group of students produced work in different infographic sub-genres in response to the lessons. The posters were shared to their blogs (see my Diigo social bookmark index for the public ones), as well as to other online accounts as part of the assessment process.

    Fast facts infographic poster by Ester van der Walt, 2017



    Infographic chart diagram by Jamie Kawalsky, 2017:




    Academic research poster by Alana Schreiber, 2017:


    These three posters exemplified the high-quality work that most students achieved and the innovation of those who departed from my academic research poster that I designed as an example for the course:



    Recommended changes to the course

    Being the first course of its kind, several ideas emerged in the process that could improve it for next year:

    Technical recommendations:

    #1 Support maximum flexibility in terms of software choice
    Many students could not make every lesson due to anxiety over their safety. Violent protests at UCT by the #feemustfall movement and the near-militarisation of campus with private security and police resulted in students feeling anxious and unsafe. In response, they were granted increasing freedom to choose the software they had access to. While most students continued to use Adobe, several chose to use Microsoft Word, one Google Docs and another infogram.com).

    #2 Prepare teaching materials on export options for best quality 
    Students found exporting imagery to be challenging and will require better support materials on achieving quality exports. This is particularly important given the varied software that students may need to use.

    #3 Prepare support material on compressing files
    For assessment, students had to submit six files to Vula, UCT's intranet. An upload limit of 4MB on particular file formats, meant that several students required email advice on compressing their files close to the submission deadline. Again, support material should be provided upfront for students on compressing the graphics in their files, creating compressed web-friendly, low-res versions and also archiving their work to .zip formats. Interestingly, the students who compressed their work in .zip files could upload large files.

    #4 Organise that fewer files have to be submitted for assessment
    Students submitted at least five files, which enabled the assessors to appreciate the process behind students' poster, rather than just the final project. While such insight proved valuable, it was highly time-consuming to assess, especially when combined with checking how students shared their work online. Consideration must be given to whether there is a more efficient way to assess the process.

    Content recommendations:

    #5 Emphasise the importance of curation as a digital literacy with new slides
    For students keen to work in data journalism, it’s highly important that they develop digital curation literacies. While this was spoken of in lessons and foregrounded through an assessment process that required students to evidence their process through uploading their source logo, chart- and poster files in addition to final work, it could be better emphasised. For example, the insights of Potter (2012) and his 'Curation and Media Education' manifesto could be drawn on for developing dedicated slides. These should highlight the benefits of having an archive of one's source documents and process, so that they can be refined, corrected or referred back in the case viewers raise concerns about their accuracy.

    #6 Provide examples for students' diverse work in the infographic genre
    Innovation was an important assessment criteria for students' work. The examples above should be used to suggest to students the wide variety of options they can choose from, rather than replicating my poster's look-and-feel, as a few defaulted to.

    #7 Present a work-in-progress for early assessment
    Rather than assessing all work at the end, a draft presentation followed by a final submission would work better next year. This will give those students who went for the wrong goalposts feedback they can use to adjust their direction.

    #8 Introduce students to how South African sociologists in education explain local educational inequalities
    To improve their analysis, students would benefit from being exposed to South African research into educational inequalities and relevant concepts from educational sociology. Students would also benefit from seeing examples of what not to do. For example, do not confuse correlation (i.e. high internet access..) with causation (... supports a high matric pass rate! Rather internet access is a marker of privilege that is often linked to households that can afford better schooling).

    N.B. You are most welcome to suggest further recommendations in the comments box below, ta!

    Total pageviews since 2008's launch.

    + TRANSLATE

    > Translate posts into your preferred language

    + SEARCH

    + or search it with these labels

    + CONNECT

    > Connect with me on social networks

    diigo education pioneer Social bookmarker @ www.diigo.com .

    About Me

    My Photo

    Visit my blog or @travisnoakes to learn more about what I do.

    + FOLLOW

    + or simply follow this blog by email

    + LISTING