Saturday, 14 November 2026
And isn’t it ironic? Like publishing an anti-scam research article, in a paper mill. Beware the journal snatcher!
![]() |
| Covert intelligence agent from Stop, dumb bot! Shushmoji set, © Create With Cape Town, 2026. |
As part of TNF’s research into digital visibility risks, I collaborated in writing ‘Resisting a Culture of ‘Fakes’: South African Celebrity Influencers’ Responses to Deepfake Social Media Endorsements’. It explores how three South African celebrity influencers respond to, and resist, deepfake social media endorsements. This negative phenomenon is a growing concern at the intersection of cybercrime, media economies, and digital cultural practices. The paper follows a critical interpretative phenomenological approach in analysing in-depth interviews to explore the meanings that public figures attach to fake endorsements, plus the social media industry. As a highly qualitative study on cybervictimisation from a growing impersonation crime in social media advertising, there were only a few suitable journal targets whose scope seemed apt.
Arriving at an International Journal of Cyber Criminology submission
We first submitted the manuscript to Social Media + Society, where it was rejected as 'not theoretically developed enough for us' (Editor in Chief's email, 17/8/25). I then tendered our paper to Crime, Media, Culture in early September, 2025. It was desk rejected by the 15th- for not focusing on 'cultural/critical criminology, but cybercrime' (email from Dr. Jennifer Fleetwood, 15/9/25). The authors then discussed whether they should continue approaching international journals, or rather focus on respected South African or African journals. The second author motivated for local journals, including 1) Communicare: Journal for Communication Studies in Africa, 2) the Journal of African Media Studies and 3) Communicatio. She highlighted how none charged compulsory APCs, and are well recognised in media and communication scholarship. By contrast, I was in favour of the greater visibility that a Quartile 1, international journal might attract, plus its related potential to drive wider readership, supporting increased citation. The IJCC was listed in the South African Department of Higher Education and Training's 2025 list as an accredited journal, published by the reputable SAGE. Consequently, I assumed that it had already been properly screened by the DHET and Stellenbosch University's Centre for Research on Evaluation, Science and Technology (CREST).
![]() |
Screenshot showing that the IJCC was listed as an accredited DHET 2025 journal |
Two days later, I submitted the manuscript to the IJCC. This paper was sent for review, revised in response to two reviewers’ feedback, then formally accepted on the 22nd of October. The APC fee was paid. Usually, the time between formal acceptance to online publication in an academic journal does not take longer than 8 weeks. This supports adequate time for formatting, author proof-checking, and layout preparation.
The first red flag 🚩 I missed was that our article was not published in this window. I should have been alarmed at the slowness of our manuscript’s publication. By contrast, I trusted that I was dealing with a reputable journal and that there were merely internal issues delaying its release of a new volume. The IJCC’s homepage continues to show its most recent volume as published for the Jan-June 2025 period, while a big blue “MAKE SUBMISSION” button suggests that the journal is still active.
Looking more closely at the homepage’s footer would have suggested the second 🚩🚩. Would a serious academic publisher be as sloppy to feature the following text: “Old Publisher: K Jaishankar New Publisher: H&N PUBLISHERS UK LIMITED is in charge of the academic discipline Cyber Criminology and he coined and defined Cyber Criminology as "the study of causation of crimes that occur in the cyberspace and its impact in the physical space". Old Publisher: K Jaishankar New Publisher: H&N PUBLISHERS UK LIMITED academically coined the term Cyber Criminology for two reasons.”
In April, 2026, I used the IJCC’s submission portal to send a query to its production manager, Muhammad Talha. I asked when the copy-edited version of our article would be available for sign-off, but received no reply. This absence should have served as a third 🚩🚩🚩. Rather than assuming a stretched workforce, I should have considered that none remained active!
On the 18th of August, 2026, I emailed select members of the IJCC’s editorial board (Professors Susan Brenner, Karuppannan Jaishankar, and Philip Ndubueze) to enquire when its next journal issue was scheduled for publication. As of the date of writing, I had not received a response. This was the fourth 🚩🚩🚩🚩, but I assumed that they were too busy to reply. However, I should have considered that they may no longer be associated with the journal despite still being listed as members on https://cybercrimejournal.com/board-team.php. Repeat after me, "Red flag assumptions are the mother of c*🤬k ups!" & "ASSuME makes an ass of you and me!"
A year later, eyes no longer open wide shut to the IJCC being dormant
![]() |
| Living imposter from Stop, dumb bot! Shushmoji set, © Create With Cape Town, 2026 |
Although the IJCC may be dormant in practice, there is no indication of this anywhere on its website. To all intents and purposes, the IJCC can still be taking submissions from naive authors who take its homepage imagery (This title is indexed in SciVerse Copus’ and ‘Support Open Access’) at face value. Likewise, the credibility associated with the esteemed members of its Editorial Board, Editorial Advisory Board, its extensive list of Abstracting and Indexing and suggested association with the South Asian Society of Criminology and Victimology. The fact that the IJCC is still scamming authors is suggested by its lowering of the APC charge from £ 2,000 (2025), to “just” $500 (2026). This is part of what Dr Robert Keller commented to be Oxbridge Publishing House's strategy of taking 'over relatively small journals and abuse the (Scopus) indexing as long as they can and cash as much as they can by publishing basically everything' (November 25, 2024).
Hindsight is 20/20, and the fifth 🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩 red flag I missed was doing an online search for the IJCC’s new owner; H&N Publishers UK Limited was incorporated on September 15, 2022. The International Journal of Cyber Criminology was handed over/acquired around mid-2022 according to Karuppannan Jaishankar (Utama, 2024). H&N Publishers UK Limited is associated with the companies Oxbridge Publishing House, Intellectual Edge and PNG Publications and Scientific Research. These are all linked to predatory academic publishing practices (Ansede, 2025. Martín-Martín and Delgado López-Cózar, 2025. Miró Llinares & Buil-Gil, 2025. Utama, 2024). In the Google Chrome, their corporate websites produce the warning "Attackers might be trying to steal your information... (for example, passwords, messages or credit cards)."
And if you are so clever, why did a journal snatcher fool you?*
While I was exposed to the importance of avoiding predatory academic journals during my PhD, I was completely unaware that the danger of ‘journal snatchers’ exists. This sees companies acquiring scholarly journals from reputable publishers — then turning legitimate titles into predatory, low-quality publications with questionable practices (Chalwa, 2025). I was also unaware of the vast extent of the predatory publishing problem, nor its rapid growth- the number of active predatory journals rose from roughly 1,800 in 2010, to about 8,000 in 2014 (Shen & Björk, 2015). An International Science Council report for 2022 states that around 150 predatory journals had been launched per month over the preceding three years, leading to a gross total of 15,000. Cabells’ Predatory Reports database has tracked such growth to 20,274 predatory journals by early 2026. By contrast, the volume of cloned/hijacked journals is low, with Retraction Watch's initial tracking figures from 2022 suggesting roughly 70–80 new ones per year (Anna Abalkina interview, 2025). Overall, the dramatic growth of predatory publishing can be explained by two major two trends (Mouton and van Niekerk, 2025): firstly, the rise of open access infrastructure, and secondly, the pervasive culture of performance management in academic culture. Professor Johann Mouton and Dr Marthie van Niekerk explain adroitly why the good intentions from both trends contribute to perverse consequences, whereby 'quantitative metrics and incentive schemes seek to reward academics for publishing as many articles as possible with no consideration of quality or integrity' (p. 34).
With the Smith's 'I know it's over' segueing into Alanis Morissette’s ‘Ironic’ 👆, I wryly smile in re-looking at the submission letter. It states, ‘The manuscript engages with platform governance and social media economies from the perspective of a global Southern context. We interrogate experiences of responding to fake content from South Africa, where authenticity and credibility are dominant cultural resources in its digital context.’ Isn’t it a little too ironic that I led TNF to chalk up the loss of the £ 2,000 APC fee, by vaingloriously publishing in a snatched journal. One in the "Global North", apparently run by a shady business network of Pakistani and Indonesian citizens (Ansede, 2025). Their business plays with the names of the prestigious universities of Oxford and Cambridge. Such a "fine target" for a 'Resisting fakes' manuscript, NOT 🤦♂️!
“My v*k, Travis!”, this has been a humbling experience- despite researching digital crime since 2023, I missed every red flag. Like a science journalist with closed vision, my 'trust heuristics' in an established journal's prestige, reputation and quality concealed other possibilities (Fleerackers, Moorhead and Alperin, 2025). Entrenched with faith in the "old" IJCC, I was blinded by ASSumptions that ultimately contributed to our manuscript’s publication being delayed by at least a year. All apologies, TNF! By submitting to a snatched journal, the goals of the intended journal selection’s increased kudos, global visibility, broader outreach, and increased citation were all thwarted. Plus, I’ve also contributed to funding an ongoing academic scam that still defrauds criminology, victimology, sociology, internet science and other expert authors from APC fees.Hopefully this post contributes to raising awareness of the journal snatching problem with scholars, helping them to avoid falling victim. Or to share with colleagues who may have already fallen victim, but just don't know it yet. Ignorance of journal snatching is not bliss 😭.
Uncountable losses from a journal snatcher
While the APC fee’s loss is a clear cost, predatory publishing and journal hijacking in this case can have many negative impacts that are incalculable: Firstly, the loss of a co-author, who stepped down due to having many other commitments versus the unanticipated need to rapidly update the paper for a new journal target. She will be acknowledged, but must lose the citation statistics linked to her contribution to the final paper. Secondly, the year-long delay negatively impacted TNF’s publication record for 'understanding digital vulnerability risks'. A missing publication undermined TNF and Scamtution’s credibility with potential funders of the 'Protecting South Africans from “petty” digital crimes’ proposal, plus related outreach. Third, is my time spent writing a ’notice of formal withdrawal’, updating the manuscript, identifying a new journal target, then submitting, and revising it. In addition, theres' time spent writing this post, then sharing it via several digital platforms. Notably: X, LinkedIn, Academia.edu, ResearchGate and Reddit. Hopefully, this contributes to readily-searchable warnings for academic authors interested in the IJCC journal that it has, in fact, become a predatory publication. For example, a positive outcome for LinkedIn's share was feedback that the IJCC is now 'under review for inclusion in the Cabells Predatory Reports database’ (Cabell’s Chief Commercial Officer's LinkedIn reply, 17/11/2026). As described in 'Brandjacked for social media advert fraud’ (2025), victims of digital crime (such as authors who’ve submitted to a journal snatcher) will have a lack of societal support in responding to cybercriminals. Consequently, prominent online scam victims often must take on the added responsibility of educating the public to avoid these new digital crimes. This is particularly important in a context where there is no public resource listing predatory POD (print-on-demand) journals. This contrasts with Retraction Watch's list of hijacked journals, and Cabell's paid-subscription service, Predatory Reports. Even these professional services confront the key technical difficulty of keeping their blacklists up-to-date, due to the pace at which new predatory publishers pop-up (ResearchGate comment from Dr Robert Keller, 2026).
Comments, please 💬
Kindly share your feedback by adding a blog comment below, cheers. Alternately contribute to a ResearchGate Q&A conversation addressing; Is there a service that flags a predatory journal's website on the site itself, like PubPeer's does on sources for retracted papers?Sources
Chalwa, D. (2025). Invasion of the ‘journal snatchers’: the firms that buy science publications and turn them rogue, Nature, https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-025-01198-6.
Fleerackers, A., Moorhead, L. L., & Alperin, J. P. (2025). “I’d Like to Think I’d Be Able to Spot One”: How Journalists Navigate Predatory Journals. Journalism Practice, 1–19. https://doi.org/10.1080/17512786.2025.2551984.
Martín-Martín, A., & Delgado López-Cózar, E. (2025). Invasion of the journal snatchers: How indexed journals are falling into questionable hands. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.14766415.
Miró Llinares, F., & Buil-Gil, D. (2025) Yet another problem for scholarly communication in criminology: The case of a Spanish journal turned into a paper mill, CRIMRXIV. https://www.crimrxiv.com/pub/f5qxodxq/release/2.
Mouton, J., & van Niekerk, M. (2025). Predatory Publishing: Drivers, Consequences, and Ethical Dilemmas. International Higher Education. https://doi.org/10.6017/895b9e0d.c470a208.
Utama, P. (2024) Fraudulent professorship in Lambung Mangkurat University, Magz Tempo (English), https://magz.tempo.co/read/investigation/42057/professorship-scandal-in-lambung-mangkurat-university.
* Sub-title's inspiration 😉 from the one like Morrissey, and the Smiths !



https://orcid.org/0000-0001-9566-8983 